IGF-I regulates bone acquisition and maintenance, even though the cellular targets and signaling pathways responsible for its action in human bone cells are poorly understood. Whether abnormalities in IGF-I action and signaling occur in human osteoblasts under conditions of net bone loss has not been determined. Herein we carried out a comparative analysis of IGF-I signaling in primary cultures of human osteoblasts from osteoporotic and control donors. In comparison with control cells, osteoporotic osteoblasts showed increased tyrosine phosphorylation of the IGF-I receptor in the basal state and blunted stimulation of receptor phosphorylation by IGF-I. Augmentation of basal IGF-I receptor phosphorylation was associated with coordinate increases in basal tyrosine phosphorylation of IRS-2 and activation of Erk, which were also minimally responsive to IGF-I stimulation. By contrast, phosphorylation levels of IRS-1, Akt, and GSK-3 were similar in the basal state in control and osteoporotic osteoblasts, and showed marked increases following IGF-I stimulation in both cell populations, even though these responses were significantly lower in the osteoporotic osteoblasts. The IGF-I signaling abnormalities in osteoporotic osteoblasts were associated with reduced DNA synthesis both under basal conditions and following stimulation with IGF-I. Interestingly, treatment of the osteoporotic osteoblasts with the MEK inhibitor PD098059 reduced the elevated levels of Erk phosphorylation and increased basal DNA synthesis. Collectively, our data show that altered osteoblast proliferation in human osteoporosis may result from dysregulation of IGF-I receptor signaling, including constitutive activation of the IRS-2/Erk signaling pathway, which becomes unresponsive to IGF-I, and defective induction of the IRS-1/Akt signaling pathway.